why hackers don’t get caught

Case files

One line per documented case, newest first. Black marks the layers the person hid behind, magenta the one investigators got through first. Open a line for the account and its sources.

People Partners, buyers and staff who know the truth. An informant, an undercover officer, a partner who cooperates.

  1. 2025Kai West"IntelBroker"Accepts bitcoin from an undercover agent
    How the anonymity failed
    On 26 January 2023 an undercover FBI agent persuaded IntelBroker to take $250 in bitcoin instead of Monero for an API key he advertised as stolen. The bitcoin wallet he gave had been funded through a wallet created by a Ramp account, and that Ramp account was registered with Kai West's UK provisional driving licence. The same licence had opened a Coinbase account in the name "Kyle Northern". A Microsoft account registered to the email address on those exchange accounts was used from the IP addresses behind the attacks, and the email account itself was accessed from the VPN address that had created an IntelBroker account on X.
    The case
    Prosecutors say that from January 2023, as "IntelBroker", Kai West started about 158 BreachForums threads offering stolen data and asked to be paid in Monero. They put victims' losses at about $25 million.
    Outcome
    Arrested in France in February 2025; the charges were unsealed in New York on 25 June 2025 and the US sought his extradition. The allegations have not been tested at trial.
    Sources

    Money

  2. 2024Tyler Robert BuchananScattered Spider / "tylerb"Registrar login from his home IP
    How the anonymity failed
    Two phishing domains used against victim companies on 2 June 2022 had been registered through one NameCheap account. NameCheap's records showed that account logging in on 4 May 2022 from an IP address that Virgin Media had leased to Buchanan. Police Scotland searched his home at that address in April 2023 and seized about 20 devices.
    The case
    Tyler Buchanan, from Dundee, Scotland, took part in a 2022 SMS phishing campaign that sent employees of tech, telecom and crypto companies to fake Okta-style login pages. He later admitted stealing at least $8 million in cryptocurrency from individual US victims.
    Outcome
    Arrested at Palma airport in Spain in June 2024 and in US custody from April 2025. He pleaded guilty in April 2026 to wire fraud conspiracy and aggravated identity theft.
    Sources

    Network

  3. 2024Dmitry Khoroshev"LockBitSupp" / LockBitCronos uncovers identity; method undisclosed
    How the anonymity failed
    In February 2024 Operation Cronos, led by the NCA, infiltrated LockBit's network and took control of its services, including the leak site. In May the NCA said that investigation had uncovered LockBitSupp's real identity, without explaining how. Separate open-source work by Brian Krebs traced old emails, reused passwords and an ICQ number to Khoroshev's earlier malware-forum identity, but Krebs says this does not by itself prove he is LockBitSupp.
    The case
    LockBit was a ransomware-as-a-service operation: its administrators built and ran the ransomware and its infrastructure, and affiliates carried out the attacks for a share of the ransom. DOJ says it hit more than 2,500 victims in at least 120 countries, including about 1,800 in the US, and that its administrator, "LockBitSupp", personally took more than $100 million. The NCA counted more than 100 hospitals and healthcare companies among its targets. LockBitSupp had publicly offered $10 million to anyone who could reveal his identity.
    Outcome
    Named on 7 May 2024, charged in a 26-count indictment in New Jersey and sanctioned by the UK, US and Australia, with a US reward of up to $10 million. LockBitSupp says the wrong man was named. He remains in Russia.
    Sources

    Infrastructure

  4. 2024Rostislav PanevLockBit developerPay reaches his named exchange accountDisputed
    How the anonymity failed
    US investigators traced the developers' 20% share of LockBit ransoms into one cluster of addresses. By amount and timing, they matched about 30 payments that left it through a mixer to deposits into an exchange account opened with his Israeli driving licence. His dark-web forum handle was tied to him too, through the bitcoin used to pay for it and IP addresses it shared with his iCloud account.
    The case
    According to the charging papers, Panev, a dual Russian-Israeli national living in Israel, wrote code for the LockBit ransomware group and held credentials to a repository containing its builder and the StealBit source code. From June 2022 to February 2024 he was paid about $10,000 a month in bitcoin.
    Disputed
    The complaint lists the crypto, forum and iCloud evidence without saying which came first, so "money" as the first-broken layer is a reading of the record, not a stated fact.
    Outcome
    Israeli authorities searched his home on 12 August 2024 and took him into custody; his computer held credentials for LockBit's panel and source code, and he admitted doing the work. Israel extradited him to the US in March 2025.
    Sources

    Money

  5. 2024Rui-Siang Lin"Pharoah" / Incognito MarketMarket funds reach his named exchange account
    How the anonymity failed
    According to the FBI affidavit as reported, bitcoin from the market's wallet went to a wallet Lin controlled, then through a swap service into Monero, and arrived at an exchange account opened with his Taiwanese driver's licence, email and phone number. The same email and phone were tied to a Namecheap account that used funds from those wallets to buy a domain promoting Incognito. He was arrested at JFK airport on 18 May 2024 while in transit.
    The case
    Incognito Market was a dark-web narcotics market that ran from October 2020 to March 2024 and sold more than $105 million in drugs, including heroin, cocaine, methamphetamine, LSD and oxycodone. Rui-Siang Lin, a Taiwanese man in his early twenties, helped found it and ran it from about January 2022. When he shut it down in March 2024 he also tried to extort people who had used the market. His day job included work for Taiwan's Ministry of Foreign Affairs.
    Outcome
    Pleaded guilty and was sentenced in February 2026 to 30 years in prison and $105 million in forfeiture.
    Sources

    Money

  6. 2024TraderTraitor (North Korea)DMM Bitcoin theft / part of the Lazarus Group, also Jade Sleet, UNC4899Fake recruiter lures Ginco employeeDisputed
    How the anonymity failed
    On 24 December 2024 Japan's National Police Agency, the FBI and the US DoD Cyber Crime Center jointly named TraderTraitor. According to the FBI, someone posing as a recruiter on LinkedIn got a Ginco employee to run a malicious Python script from GitHub as a pre-employment test. The attackers then used stolen session cookies to impersonate that employee and likely altered a legitimate DMM transaction request.
    The case
    In late May 2024, 4,502.9 BTC (about ¥48.2 billion) was stolen from the Japanese exchange DMM Bitcoin. The theft went through Ginco, the wallet-software company that handled its transfers.
    Disputed
    The agencies did not explain what evidence tied the theft to TraderTraitor. The NPA says only that it assessed the investigation by its Kanto regional cyber unit and the Tokyo police.
    Outcome
    No one has been charged. The result is a public attribution to a North Korean state-backed group.
    Sources

    Attribution

  7. 2023Deniss Zolotarjovs"Sforza_cesarini" (Karakurt)Ransom merged with his exchange coins
    How the anonymity failed
    A source gave the FBI the group's Rocket.Chat, hosted on Tor. Investigators traced 10% of one victim's September 2021 ransom through a mixer to a new cluster of bitcoin addresses. In a single transaction that cluster combined those coins with 1.39 BTC that had just arrived from a US exchange account registered in his name. Matching IP addresses then tied his iCloud account to the messenger IDs of Sforza_cesarini, his handle in Karakurt. In November 2023 he asked the editor of a security blog to help pressure victims. The editor contacted the FBI, and he then asked the FBI for about $365,000 in exchange for information.
    The case
    Zolotarjovs, a Latvian living in Moscow, negotiated for the Karakurt extortion group and pressed victims who had stopped responding. According to the DOJ, the group stole data from more than 54 companies between 2021 and 2023.
    Outcome
    He was arrested in Georgia in December 2023 and extradited in August 2024. He pleaded guilty in July 2025 and on 4 May 2026 was sentenced to 102 months in prison.
    Sources

    Money

  8. 2023Christina ChapmanDPRK IT-worker laptop farmHome searched; laptop farm found
    How the anonymity failed
    The company laptops sat in Chapman's Arizona home, so the workers appeared to connect from US residential addresses. That relay was a physical house run by a real person. In September to October 2023 a customer of a separate laptop farm run by Oleksandr Didenko asked him to send a computer to Chapman's farm, which DOJ cites as showing the cells were connected; the October 2023 search of her home found more than 90 laptops, many labelled with the company and identity they served.
    The case
    North Korea places IT workers abroad who apply for remote jobs under false identities and send their wages back to the regime. Christina Chapman, a 50-year-old woman in Arizona, helped such workers use 68 stolen identities of US people to get jobs at 309 US companies and two foreign ones. She received and hosted their company laptops, shipped others abroad and handled their pay. The scheme brought in more than $17.1 million, and DOJ called it one of the largest North Korean IT-worker fraud schemes it had charged.
    Outcome
    Charged in May 2024, pleaded guilty on 11 February 2025 and sentenced on 24 July 2025 to 102 months in prison. The scheme generated more than $17.1 million.
    Sources

    Infrastructure

  9. 2023Conor Brian FitzpatrickBreachForums / "pompompurin"Forum logins from his own phone
    How the anonymity failed
    The FBI obtained images of the seized RaidForums servers, whose database logged pompompurin's logins. Verizon records matched at least nine of those IP addresses to phones registered to Fitzpatrick at his home in Peekskill, New York. The same database held a 2020 chat in which he mentioned his own old Gmail address; that, with records from Google and Purse.io, tied the handle to him further.
    The case
    BreachForums was a forum for buying and selling stolen databases, opened in March 2022 as a successor to RaidForums, whose servers the FBI later seized. It claimed more than 340,000 members, and prosecutors said Conor Fitzpatrick ran it as "pompompurin".
    Outcome
    Arrested on 15 March 2023, he pleaded guilty in July 2023 and in January 2024 received time served (17 days) plus 20 years of supervised release. The Fourth Circuit vacated that sentence, and on 16 September 2025 he was resentenced to three years in prison.
    Sources

    Network

  10. 2022Vyacheslav Penchukov"tank" (Jabber Zeus, IcedID)Announces daughter's birth in chatDisputed
    How the anonymity failed
    The crew's chat server, hosted in Brooklyn, kept extensive chat logs, and the FBI searched it under warrant. In a chat on 22 July 2009 tank announced his daughter's birth, giving her name and birth weight. Researcher Gary Warner wrote that only one Ukrainian birth record matched, and that the father on it was Penchukov. He escaped a Ukrainian raid in 2010. In October 2022 he was arrested after travelling to Geneva; Krebs's sources say he went there to meet his wife.
    The case
    From 2009, as "tank", Penchukov helped run the Jabber Zeus crew, which used Zeus malware to drain US business bank accounts through money mules. From 2018 to 2021 he also helped run the IcedID malware operation.
    Disputed
    The birth-record link comes from a researcher's blog, not a court filing, and the wife-visit detail from Krebs's unnamed sources.
    Outcome
    Swiss authorities arrested him on 23 October 2022 and he was extradited to the US in 2023. He pleaded guilty in February 2024 and in July 2024 was sentenced to nine years in prison and $73 million in restitution.
    Sources

    Behavior

  11. 2022Mikhail Matveev"Wazawaka" / "m1x" / BabukSame emails reused across old accounts
    How the anonymity failed
    Brian Krebs connected the handle to Matveev through more than a decade of reused details in breach data and registration records. Wazawaka's forum accounts shared a small set of passwords and Yandex and Mail.ru addresses; one of those addresses registered a VKontakte account for Mikhail "Mix" Matveev and a domain originally registered to a Mikhail Matveyev in Abakan. The phone number on that VK account reappeared in another domain registration, and the ICQ number Wazawaka gave on the Exploit forum matched a 2009 account on a forum in the same region. US authorities named and charged him the following year.
    The case
    Mikhail Matveev, a Russian national from Kaliningrad, is accused of working as an affiliate of three ransomware operations, LockBit, Babuk and Hive, from at least 2020. Prosecutors say the attacks included the June 2020 LockBit attack on a police agency in Passaic County, New Jersey, the April 2021 Babuk attack on the Metropolitan Police Department in Washington, D.C., and a 2022 Hive attack on a New Jersey behavioral health nonprofit. Under the name Wazawaka he was also known on Russian-language crime forums as a broker selling access to hacked networks.
    Outcome
    Indictments in New Jersey and Washington, D.C. were unsealed on 16 May 2023, alongside US sanctions and a State Department reward of up to $10 million. He lives in Russia and is not in US custody.
    Sources

    Identity

  12. 2022Mark SokolovskyRaccoon Infostealer ("Photix")Forum Gmail tied to his own iCloudDisputed
    How the anonymity failed
    According to two unnamed sources quoted by KrebsOnSecurity, the Gmail account behind the Photix persona was linked to an Apple iCloud account in his own name, and investigators followed his phone's location through it. A DOJ court filing confirms he left Ukraine on 4 March 2022 in what appeared to be a Porsche Cayenne and crossed Poland and Germany into the Netherlands. The same sources say the woman travelling with him posted the trip on Instagram.
    The case
    Raccoon Infostealer was malware rented to other criminals for about $200 a month to steal passwords and financial data from victims' computers. Sokolovsky, a Ukrainian, ran it under the forum persona "Photix".
    Disputed
    The Gmail-iCloud link and the Instagram detail come only from unnamed sources; the DOJ filings do not say how he was identified. The widely repeated version, in which the Instagram posts of the woman travelling with him gave him away, goes further than that report, which credits the phone tracking.
    Outcome
    Dutch police arrested him on 20 March 2022 on a US provisional warrant, and he was extradited in February 2024. After a plea deal he was sentenced in December 2024 to five years in prison.
    Sources

    Identity

  13. 2022Arion Kurtaj"White" / Lapsus$IPs behind his boasting accounts
    How the anonymity failed
    Prosecutors told the court that investigators found Kurtaj and a co-defendant by resolving the IP addresses behind email and Telegram accounts the pair used to boast about their attacks. Separately, after he bought the doxing site Doxbin and leaked its data in January 2022, members of that community published a detailed dox of him, his family and his UK home. Whether police relied on it is not public. While on bail he kept hacking, including Rockstar Games through an Amazon Fire Stick on a hotel TV.
    The case
    Lapsus$ was a data-extortion group, largely made up of teenagers, that in 2021 and 2022 broke into large companies, stole data and threatened to leak it, often announcing its attacks on Telegram. Arion Kurtaj was described in court as a key member. The offences proved against him included breaches at Uber, the fintech firm Revolut and Rockstar Games, where footage of the unreleased Grand Theft Auto VI was leaked. He was a teenager at the time and has severe autism.
    Outcome
    Found unfit to stand trial; in August 2023 a jury found he had committed the acts, and in December 2023 he received an indefinite hospital order. In July 2026 BBC correspondent Joe Tidy reported he had been moved from the secure hospital to prison to await a criminal trial, which the report said was due in November 2026.
    Sources

    Network

  14. 2022Ilya Lichtenstein and Heather MorganBitfinex hack launderingStolen coins start moving through AlphaBay
    How the anonymity failed
    Most of the stolen coins sat in one wallet for years while smaller amounts were moved, starting with deposits to accounts on the AlphaBay darknet market, then through chains of transactions, mixers and other currencies. Investigators followed the movements on the public ledger to accounts tied to the couple. A 2021 search warrant on Lichtenstein's US cloud storage account produced encrypted files; on 31 January 2022 agents decrypted one listing about 2,000 addresses with their private keys, which let them take the main wallet.
    The case
    In August 2016 a hacker broke into the cryptocurrency exchange Bitfinex and stole about 120,000 bitcoin. For years the coins barely moved while the culprit remained unknown. In February 2022 US authorities arrested Ilya Lichtenstein and his wife Heather Morgan in New York for laundering the funds and seized about 94,600 BTC of the stolen coins. Lichtenstein later admitted he had carried out the hack himself; Morgan joined the laundering years after it.
    Outcome
    Both pleaded guilty in August 2023; Lichtenstein admitted to the 2016 hack itself. He was sentenced on 14 November 2024 to five years and Morgan to 18 months. Lichtenstein was released to home confinement under the First Step Act in January 2026.
    Sources

    Money

  15. 2021Joseph James O'Connor"PlugwalkJoe"Contacts investigator, later gives his name
    How the anonymity failed
    From January 2019 a man calling himself "PlugwalkJoe" was in touch with an investigator at California's REACT task force. Asked later for his name, he said Joseph O'Connor, and said he had moved to Spain. After the Twitter hack he texted the investigator and called REACT's general line from a Google Voice number. The email account behind that number had logged in from a VPN address that @PlugwalkJoe used in 2018. Other VPN addresses, each used by more than one account within minutes, linked his Snapchat, Instagram and Discord accounts.
    The case
    Joseph O'Connor, a British national living in Spain, was charged over the July 2020 Twitter hijacking and over TikTok and Snapchat account takeovers. He routed his logins through VPNs such as M247.
    Outcome
    Arrested in Estepona, Spain, on 21 July 2021. After extradition he was sentenced in the US on 23 June 2023 to five years in prison.
    Sources

    Behavior

  16. 2020Graham Ivan Clark, Mason Sheppard and others2020 Twitter hackHack bitcoin flows to KYC exchanges
    How the anonymity failed
    IRS-CI analysts traced the scam's bitcoin. Coins sent from the "Chaewon" wallet to "Kirk" matched payment requests in their Discord chats, and the same wallet dealt heavily with Binance accounts; Binance and Coinbase then produced records including Mason Sheppard's driver's licence, date of birth and address. A leaked copy of the OGUsers forum database independently linked "Chaewon" to a second account through a shared IP address.
    The case
    On 15 July 2020 attackers took over about 130 Twitter accounts belonging to politicians, celebrities and companies and used them to post a scam promising to double any bitcoin sent to an address. They had reached Twitter's internal administration tools by socially engineering staff. The scam collected more than $100,000, and the accounts of Barack Obama, Joe Biden and Elon Musk were among those used. The alleged leader, Graham Ivan Clark, was 17.
    Outcome
    Charges were announced on 31 July 2020. Clark, 17 at the time, took a Florida plea in March 2021 for three years in juvenile prison and three years of probation. Joseph O'Connor ("PlugwalkJoe") was sentenced in New York on 23 June 2023 to five years.
    Sources

    Money

  17. 202031 men who swapped stolen NEMBuyers of the Coincheck NEM lootSwapped coins reach regular exchangesDisputed
    How the anonymity failed
    The Tokyo Metropolitan Police followed the NEM past the dark-web swap to ordinary exchanges, where they identified the registered account holders.
    The case
    In January 2018 about ¥58 billion of NEM was stolen from the exchange Coincheck, and the thieves offered it for other crypto on a dark-web site. Buyers who allegedly knew it was stolen swapped it for bitcoin and other coins in February and March 2018.
    Disputed
    These were buyers of the stolen coins. The press reports cited here do not say anyone was charged over the theft itself.
    Outcome
    The first two arrests, a company executive in Osaka and a doctor in Hokkaido, came on 11 March 2020. By January 2021 police had arrested or referred to prosecutors 31 men in 13 prefectures on suspicion of receiving about ¥18.8 billion in criminal proceeds. Six of them were arrested.
    Sources

    Money

  18. 2019Maksim Yakubets"aqua" (Jabber Zeus, later Evil Corp)Gives personal email in chat
    How the anonymity failed
    The FBI read the crew's chat logs on a server it searched under warrant. In one chat, on 11 August 2009, aqua told tank to send a phone number to aquamo@mail.ru. At US request, Russian police checked that inbox and found mail addressed to "Maksim Yakubets", his travel bookings and the delivery of a baby carriage to a Moscow address. Microsoft records later tied the same address to a Skype account named "maksim.ya".
    The case
    As "aqua", Yakubets arranged the money mules who moved funds the Jabber Zeus crew stole in 2009-2010. The US Treasury later named him the leader of Evil Corp, the group behind the Dridex malware.
    Outcome
    A complaint charging him was sworn on 14 November 2019 and unsealed in December, when the US sanctioned Evil Corp and offered $5 million for information leading to his capture.
    Sources

    Identity

  19. 2018Son Jong-wooWelcome to VideoSite bitcoin lands in his named account
    How the anonymity failed
    IRS-CI agents paid into the site's bitcoin addresses and followed the withdrawals to a wallet hosted at an exchange, which held Son's name, phone number and email address. The DOJ release credits bitcoin tracing with locating both the administrator and the server in South Korea. Press summaries of the indictment add that one page loaded files by the server's raw IP address instead of the onion address, which pointed to a Korea Telecom connection.
    The case
    Welcome to Video was a Tor site that sold child sexual abuse videos for bitcoin. DOJ called it the largest such market by volume of content; Korean reporting put the collection at more than 250,000 videos, about 8 TB. Its operator, Son Jong-woo, was a South Korean in his early twenties. The takedown in 2018 and the US indictment unsealed in 2019 led to charges against hundreds of users in many countries.
    Outcome
    Arrested in South Korea on 5 March 2018 and served 18 months there. Seoul High Court refused US extradition on 6 July 2020. In July 2022 a Korean court gave him two more years for concealing the proceeds. The US case led to charges against hundreds of site users worldwide.
    Sources

    Money

  20. 2018GRU Units 26165 and 74455"Guccifer 2.0" / DCLeaksGRU server searched G2's English phrasesDisputed
    How the anonymity failed
    The 2018 indictment ties the persona to GRU infrastructure: on 15 June 2016 the conspirators logged into a Moscow server managed by Unit 74455 and searched for English phrases that appeared in Guccifer 2.0's first post that day. The same pool of bitcoin paid for a VPN account later used to log into the @Guccifer_2 Twitter account and for the Malaysian server that hosted dcleaks.com.
    The case
    In 2016 Russian military intelligence (GRU) officers hacked the Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee, the Democratic National Committee and the Clinton campaign, then released the stolen documents through the personas "DCLeaks" and "Guccifer 2.0" during the US presidential election. "Guccifer 2.0" claimed to be a lone Romanian hacker and contacted journalists directly. The 2018 indictment charged twelve officers of GRU Units 26165 and 74455 and described the operation as interference in the election.
    Disputed
    The often-repeated network slip, that the operator once forgot to turn on the VPN and left a Moscow IP address in a US social media company's logs, comes from a single Daily Beast report based on an unnamed source. It is not in the indictment, and the indictment does not say how investigators obtained the activity on the Moscow server.
    Outcome
    Twelve GRU officers were indicted in the District of Columbia on 13 July 2018. None is in US custody.
    Sources

    Infrastructure

  21. 2017Buster Hernandez"Brian Kil"Plays the booby-trapped victim videoDisputed
    How the anonymity failed
    In June 2017 a judge authorised the FBI to plant a network investigative technique (NIT) in a video made by a victim and shared through a Dropbox account he used. When he played it, the video sent his real IP address to the FBI, which led agents to his home in Bakersfield, California. Motherboard later reported that Facebook had paid a firm to build the exploit, which targeted Tails' video player.
    The case
    Using "Brian Kil" and many other Facebook accounts, Hernandez extorted sexual images from minors and threatened shootings and bombings at schools in Indiana, which closed in December 2015. He connected through Tor using the Tails operating system.
    Disputed
    Facebook's role rests on Motherboard's unnamed sources; Facebook confirmed only that it worked with "security experts", and the FBI declined to comment.
    Outcome
    An arrest warrant was issued on 1 August 2017. He pleaded guilty to 41 counts in February 2020 and was sentenced to 75 years in March 2021.
    Sources

    Device

  22. 2017Alexandre Cazes"Alpha02" / AlphaBayHotmail address in site emails
    How the anonymity failed
    For a short period after the forum launched in December 2014, AlphaBay's welcome and password-recovery emails carried Cazes's personal Hotmail address, pimp_alex_91@hotmail.com, in the header. Investigators learned this in December 2016 and followed the address to an older tech-forum profile under the handle Alpha02, to PayPal accounts in his name and to his company. When Thai police arrested him in Bangkok on 5 July 2017, his laptop was open, unencrypted and logged in to AlphaBay as admin.
    The case
    AlphaBay was the largest dark-web market when it was taken down in July 2017. It sold drugs, stolen data, malware and other illegal goods, had more than 400,000 users and, according to the FBI, was about ten times the size of Silk Road. Alexandre Cazes, a 25-year-old Canadian living in Thailand, was its creator and administrator. The takedown was coordinated with the Dutch seizure of Hansa Market, another major market.
    Outcome
    Died in Thai custody on 12 July 2017, an apparent suicide. The criminal case was dismissed after his death and his assets were pursued through civil forfeiture in the Eastern District of California.
    Sources

    Identity

  23. 2015Steven W. ChasePlaypenHidden service leaks its real US IP
    How the anonymity failed
    In December 2014 a foreign law-enforcement agency told the FBI that the Tor hidden service's real IP address was visible and resolved to the United States. The FBI seized the server at a hosting facility in North Carolina, served warrants on email accounts and followed the payments, which led to Chase. The FBI then ran the site for about two weeks and used a "network investigative technique", an exploit against visitors' browsers, to collect their real addresses.
    The case
    Playpen was a members-only child sexual abuse website on Tor, created by Steven Chase in August 2014. It grew to more than 150,000 users worldwide. In January 2015 the FBI launched Operation Pacifier against its members, and the FBI reported that 296 sexually abused children were identified or rescued.
    Outcome
    Arrested in February 2015 and convicted by a jury of engaging in a child exploitation enterprise. Sentenced on 1 May 2017 to 30 years in prison; two co-administrators received 20 years each.
    Sources

    Infrastructure

  24. 2015Ardit Ferizi"Th3Dir3ctorY"Same IP for hack and Twitter
    How the anonymity failed
    The image of the victim company's server showed the SQL injection coming from 210.186.111.14, an address at a Malaysian ISP. Records from Twitter and Facebook showed the same address logging into his @Th3Dir3ctorY account and his personal Facebook account during the same days in July 2015. He had also left an administrator account named "KHS" on the server, the initials of his Kosova Hacker's Security group.
    The case
    Ardit Ferizi was a 20-year-old Kosovo citizen living in Malaysia who led a hacking group called Kosova Hacker's Security. In 2015 he broke into the server of a US online retailer and pulled out personal data, then selected about 1,300 records belonging to US military members and government personnel. He gave that list to Junaid Hussain, a member of ISIL, who published it online.
    Outcome
    Detained in Malaysia on a US provisional warrant, extradited in January 2016, pleaded guilty in June 2016 and sentenced on 23 September 2016 to 20 years for providing material support to ISIL and unauthorized access.
    Sources

    Network

  25. 2014Blake Benthall"Defcon" / Silk Road 2.0Server found; hosting account in his name
    How the anonymity failed
    In May 2014 the FBI identified a server in another country that was hosting Silk Road 2.0; the complaint does not say how. The hosting provider's records showed the server was controlled by someone using the address blake@benthall.net. Separately, an HSI undercover agent had joined the site's support staff and had access to the admin-only areas, which gave investigators a view from inside the operation.
    The case
    Silk Road 2.0 appeared soon after the original Silk Road was seized in October 2013 and copied its look and function. Prosecutors said Blake Benthall, a 26-year-old in San Francisco, ran it from around December 2013. By September 2014 it was generating at least about $8 million in sales a month and had about 150,000 active users.
    Outcome
    Arrested in San Francisco on 5 November 2014. He cooperated; a DOJ agreement reported in May 2019 said he would not be further prosecuted for running the site except for criminal tax violations. No public sentencing record was found.
    Sources

    Infrastructure

  26. 2013Ross UlbrichtSilk Road / "Dread Pirate Roberts"Bitcoin Talk job ad gives his GmailDisputed
    How the anonymity failed
    An IRS special agent searched for the earliest mentions of Silk Road and found a user called "altoid" promoting it on Bitcoin forums in January 2011. Later posts under the same handle gave rossulbricht@gmail.com as a contact address. A search warrant then brought the Gmail account's contents from Google. The pseudonym on the market was never broken directly; an old handle, used before the operation was locked down, tied it to a real-name address.
    The case
    Silk Road was an online market reachable only through Tor, run from January 2011 until the FBI seized it in October 2013. It sold mainly illegal drugs and took payment only in bitcoin. Prosecutors said Ross Ulbricht created it and, as "Dread Pirate Roberts", controlled every part of it, including a paid staff of administrators and programmers. The court later ordered him to forfeit about $184 million.
    Disputed
    How the FBI found the Silk Road server is contested. Government filings said its real IP address leaked through the login page's CAPTCHA. The defence, and researcher Nicholas Weaver after reading the server configuration and logs the government produced, said the server only accepted connections from the Tor front end and that the logs showed agents fetching a phpMyAdmin page, not a CAPTCHA.
    Outcome
    Indicted in February 2014 and convicted on all seven counts on 5 February 2015. Sentenced on 29 May 2015 to life in prison and ordered to forfeit about $184 million. President Trump granted him a full pardon on 21 January 2025.
    Sources

    Identity

  27. 2013Yusuke KatayamaRemote-control virus caseFilmed collaring the Enoshima cat
    How the anonymity failed
    The virus relayed every post through victims' machines and Tor, so the network trail ended at innocent people. The case broke in the physical world: in January 2013 the culprit's own emailed puzzle led to a memory card on the collar of a cat on Enoshima, and security cameras there had recorded Katayama near the cat. After he was released on bail while denying everything, police watched him bury a smartphone on a Tokyo riverbank; it held traces of a fake "real culprit" email sent in May 2014.
    The case
    Between June and September 2012, someone infected other people's PCs with a remote-control virus and used them to post threats online, including a threat to attack a kindergarten. Police in Osaka, Mie, Tokyo and Kanagawa arrested four men whose computers had sent the threats, and two of them confessed under interrogation. In December 2012 the four police forces admitted the arrests were wrong and that their interviews had been inappropriate. A joint task force of about 160 officers then hunted the real author, Yusuke Katayama, a 30-year-old IT company employee.
    Outcome
    Arrested on 10 February 2013. After the riverbank phone was found he confessed to his lawyer on 19 May 2014 and admitted all charges in court. The Tokyo District Court sentenced him on 4 February 2015 to eight years (prosecutors had sought ten).
    Sources

    Behavior

  28. 2013Eric Eoin MarquesFreedom HostingFrench server located; method undisclosed
    How the anonymity failed
    Investigators located a server in France behind the Tor hidden-service host; the government has never explained how. US authorities alleged that the server space was rented from a French company, paid for with a debit card on a US bank account and billed to a private mailbox near Las Vegas, which pointed at Marques. After taking control of the service the FBI served code to visitors that exploited a Firefox flaw to reveal their real addresses, an attack on the users' devices rather than on Marques.
    The case
    Freedom Hosting was a hosting service on the Tor network that Eric Eoin Marques ran from 2008 to 2013. DOJ says it hosted more than 200 child sexual exploitation websites holding millions of images, and investigators found more than 8.5 million images and videos on the server. Prosecutors called him one of the largest facilitators of child sexual abuse material in the world.
    Outcome
    Arrested in Dublin in 2013 and extradited to Maryland in March 2019. Pleaded guilty in February 2020 to conspiracy to advertise child sexual abuse material and was sentenced in September 2021 to 27 years in prison.
    Sources

    Infrastructure

  29. 2013Eldo KimHarvard bomb hoaxTor used on Harvard's logged Wi-Fi
    How the anonymity failed
    The threats were sent from a disposable mail service over Tor, so the messages themselves carried no usable address. But Harvard's wireless network required users to log in, and the university could tell that Kim had connected to Tor from it in the hours before the emails arrived. Tor hid what he did, not that he was using Tor on a small, logged network at that moment. Interviewed by the FBI and Harvard police, he admitted sending the emails to avoid a final exam.
    The case
    On the morning of 16 December 2013, Harvard University police, two university officials and the president of The Harvard Crimson received emails saying bombs had been placed in four campus buildings. The buildings were evacuated during final exams and no explosives were found. Eldo Kim, a 20-year-old student, was due to sit an exam in one of those buildings that morning. The case became a standard example of what Tor does and does not hide.
    Outcome
    Charged by complaint in December 2013. In October 2014 prosecutors agreed to an 18-month pretrial diversion with four months of home confinement, 750 hours of community service and restitution, after which the charge would be dismissed.
    Sources

    Network

  30. 2012Jeremy Hammond"Anarchaos" / "sup_g" / AntiSecChats with informant reveal his past
    How the anonymity failed
    Hammond planned and discussed the December 2011 Stratfor hack in chats with Sabu, who was already working for the FBI. In those chats he mentioned past arrests at protests and time in federal prison, and the FBI agent on the case matched those details against arrest records to narrow the suspects to him. Sabu also tied the handle "sup_g" to "Anarchaos", an alias already linked to Hammond.
    The case
    Jeremy Hammond was a Chicago activist and hacker who took part in AntiSec, an offshoot of Anonymous. In December 2011 he and others broke into Strategic Forecasting (Stratfor), a private intelligence firm in Austin, Texas, and took employees' emails and account data for about 860,000 subscribers and clients. Prosecutors also tied him to attacks on law-enforcement and government websites.
    Outcome
    Arrested in Chicago in March 2012. Pleaded guilty in May 2013 to one count of conspiracy to commit computer hacking and was sentenced on 15 November 2013 to 10 years in prison.
    Sources

    People

  31. 2011Hector Xavier Monsegur"Sabu" / LulzSecIRC login from his own IPDisputed
    How the anonymity failed
    According to Fox News, which broke the story, Sabu normally hid his address behind proxies but once logged into an IRC server from his own IP address, which let the FBI tie the handle to him. He was arrested on 7 June 2011 and pleaded guilty on 15 August 2011. He then worked as an informant, and prosecutors credited his cooperation with identifying other LulzSec and AntiSec members.
    The case
    Hector Xavier Monsegur, known as "Sabu", was a New York hacker and a leading figure in groups aligned with Anonymous. In May 2011 he and three others formed LulzSec, which broke into and leaked data from companies and government bodies through mid-2011. He pleaded guilty in secret in August 2011, and when his plea was unsealed in March 2012, five other hackers were charged on the same day. The case showed how far one cooperating insider could reach into a loosely organized hacking scene.
    Disputed
    The single-IRC-login account comes from one Fox News report without a named source and is not in the charging documents. Monsegur says he always connected through hacked machines and was instead identified from an older dox posted about him on EFnet IRC, which agents later obtained. On his account the failure was identity, not network.
    Outcome
    Sentenced on 27 May 2014 to time served (about seven months) plus one year of supervised release, with the judge citing his "extraordinary cooperation".
    Sources

    Network

the slip that later pointed at the personapproximate datearrestedcharged or named, not arrested2009201120132015201720192021202320252027Hector Xavier MonsegurIRC login from his own IPdate of the slip not publicJeremy HammondChats with informant reveal his past3 mo laterYusuke KatayamaFilmed collaring the Enoshima catwithin a monthEric Eoin MarquesFrench server located; method undiscloseddate of the slip not publicRoss UlbrichtBitcoin Talk job ad gives his Gmail2.0 yr laterEldo KimTor used on Harvard's logged Wi-Fiwithin a monthBlake BenthallServer found; hosting account in his name6 mo laterSteven W. ChaseHidden service leaks its real US IP2 mo laterArdit FeriziSame IP for hack and Twitter2 mo laterAlexandre CazesHotmail address in site emails2.6 yr laterBuster HernandezPlays the booby-trapped victim video2 mo laterSon Jong-wooSite bitcoin lands in his named account6 mo laterGRU Units 26165 and 74455GRU server searched G2's English phrases2.1 yr laterMaksim YakubetsGives personal email in chat10.3 yr later31 men who swapped stolen NEMSwapped coins reach regular exchanges2.1 yr laterGraham Ivan Clark, Mason Sheppard and othersHack bitcoin flows to KYC exchangeswithin a monthJoseph James O'ConnorContacts investigator, later gives his name2.5 yr laterArion KurtajIPs behind his boasting accountsdate of the slip not publicIlya Lichtenstein and Heather MorganStolen coins start moving through AlphaBay5.1 yr laterMark SokolovskyForum Gmail tied to his own iClouddate of the slip not publicVyacheslav PenchukovAnnounces daughter's birth in chat13.3 yr laterConor Brian FitzpatrickForum logins from his own phone2.2 yr laterMikhail MatveevSame emails reused across old accounts13.8 yr laterDeniss ZolotarjovsRansom merged with his exchange coins2.2 yr laterDmitry KhoroshevCronos uncovers identity; method undiscloseddate of the slip not publicChristina ChapmanHome searched; laptop farm found7 mo laterRui-Siang LinMarket funds reach his named exchange account2.8 yr laterTyler Robert BuchananRegistrar login from his home IP2.1 yr laterRostislav PanevPay reaches his named exchange account2.2 yr laterTraderTraitor (North Korea)Fake recruiter lures Ginco employee9 mo laterKai WestAccepts bitcoin from an undercover agent2.1 yr later
When the slip happened, and when the person was arrested or charged. Of the 26 files where the slip can be dated, 14 waited two years or more. The reused email addresses that named Mikhail Matveev were nearly 14 years old.