Several open-source projects describe themselves as inspired by or modelled on Zanzibar. This page lines six of them up against the paper, one concern per table. Cells are short; the sources for every row are listed under each table. Facts were checked on 2026-11-13 and come from each project’s own repository and documentation, so most are vendor-authored.
The six: SpiceDB (AuthZed), OpenFGA (CNCF), Permify (FusionAuth), Ory Keto (Ory), Topaz (its maintainers, after Aserto wound down) and Warrant (WorkOS). Each has its own page: SpiceDB, OpenFGA, Permify, Ory Keto, Topaz, Warrant.
Schema language
The paper calls it a namespace configuration: relations with userset rewrite rules (§2.3). Figure 1 writes one in a protocol-buffer-style text syntax; the paper does not name the format.
| System | Schema language | Format |
|---|---|---|
| Paper | Namespace config | Protobuf-style text in Figure 1 (format not named) |
| SpiceDB | Schema (definition, relation, permission) |
Own language |
| OpenFGA | Authorization model (type, define) |
DSL, compiled to JSON |
| Permify | Permify Schema (entity, relation, permission / action, attribute, rule) |
Own language |
| Ory Keto | Ory Permission Language (OPL) | TypeScript subset |
| Topaz | Manifest (types, relations, permissions) |
YAML, version: 3 |
| Warrant | Object types (inheritIf, rules) |
JSON |
Sources: SpiceDB schema · OpenFGA configuration language · Permify modeling · Ory Permission Language · Topaz manifest reference · Warrant spec.go
Tuple syntax
The paper writes a tuple as object#relation@user, where the user can itself be a userset object#relation (§2.1). The rows below show Beto’s group being viewers of the readme where the docs give a string form.
| System | Name | Shape |
|---|---|---|
| Paper | Relation tuple | doc:readme#viewer@group:eng#member |
| SpiceDB | Relationship | doc:readme#viewer@group:eng#member |
| OpenFGA | Relationship tuple | user group:eng#member, relation viewer, object doc:readme |
| Permify | Relational tuple | doc:readme#viewer@group:eng#member |
| Ory Keto | Relation tuple | Doc:readme#viewers@Group:eng#members |
| Topaz | Relation | Fields object_type, object_id, relation, subject_type, subject_id, optional subject_relation |
| Warrant | Warrant | [user:1] is an [editor] of [document:docA] (README’s example) |
Sources: SpiceDB relationships · OpenFGA concepts · Permify sync data · Ory Keto relation tuples · Topaz common.proto · Warrant README
Rewrite operators
The paper’s rewrite rules combine three leaves, _this, computed_userset and tuple_to_userset, with union, intersection and exclusion (§2.3.1).
| System | Union / intersection / exclusion | computed_userset | tuple_to_userset |
|---|---|---|---|
| Paper | union / intersection / exclusion |
computed_userset |
tuple_to_userset |
| SpiceDB | + / & / - |
Name a relation or permission | parent->view (also .any(); .all() intersects) |
| OpenFGA | or / and / but not |
Bare relation name | viewer from parent |
| Permify | or / and / not |
Bare name | Dot: org.admin |
| Ory Keto | || / && / ! |
this.permits.x(ctx) |
.traverse(...) |
| Topaz | | / & / - |
Name a relation or permission | parent->can_read |
| Warrant | anyOf / allOf / noneOf |
inheritIf |
ofType + withRelation |
Sources: SpiceDB schema · OpenFGA equivalent Zanzibar concepts · Permify modeling · Ory Permission Language · Topaz manifest reference · Warrant spec.go
Consistency token and modes
The paper’s zookie is “an opaque byte sequence encoding a globally meaningful timestamp” (§2.4); a check is evaluated at a snapshot no earlier than the zookie it carries (§2.2, §2.4.4).
| System | Token | Modes or behaviour |
|---|---|---|
| Paper | Zookie | With zookie: at least as fresh; without: “a reasonably recent snapshot” (§2.4.1) |
| SpiceDB | ZedToken | minimize_latency, at_least_as_fresh, at_exact_snapshot, fully_consistent |
| OpenFGA | None | MINIMIZE_LATENCY (default), HIGHER_CONSISTENCY; cache off by default |
| Permify | Snap Token | Returned by Write, passed to Check as snap_token; without one, the latest transaction |
| Ory Keto | snaptoken field |
“not implemented yet and has no effect” |
| Topaz | None documented | No token fields in the reader API |
| Warrant | Warrant-Token header |
The open-source server returns no token and acts only on latest, which sends the read to the primary database |
Sources: SpiceDB consistency · OpenFGA consistency · Permify snap tokens · Keto check_service.proto · Topaz reader.proto · Warrant wookie.go, sql.go, warrant/service.go
Which products carry something in the zookie’s place?
Notice that only the two solid links let an application say “at least as fresh as my write”, which is what protects against the new-enemy problem in the paper (§2.2).
Watch and changelog
The paper’s Watch streams tuple changes from a changelog, with heartbeat zookies to resume from (§2.4.3, §3).
| System | API | Shape |
|---|---|---|
| Paper | Watch | Stream, resumable with a zookie |
| SpiceDB | Watch |
Stream, resumable with a ZedToken (changes_through) |
| OpenFGA | ReadChanges |
Paginated read with a continuation token (polled) |
| Permify | Watch |
Stream (stream WatchResponse) |
| Ory Keto | None | No watch service in the protocol files |
| Topaz | None | No watch service in the protocol files |
| Warrant | None | No change or event endpoint in the repository |
Sources: SpiceDB watch_service.proto · OpenFGA openfga_service.proto · Permify service.proto · Keto protos · Topaz go-directory protos · Warrant repository
Leopard-like index
Leopard is the paper’s index for large and deeply nested groups, built from snapshots and Watch updates (§3.2.4).
| System | Precomputed index | Note |
|---|---|---|
| Paper | Leopard | Serving, offline and incremental parts (§3.2.4) |
| SpiceDB | AuthZed Materialize | Commercial, for AuthZed Dedicated customers; “takes inspiration from the Leopard index component” |
| OpenFGA | None documented | Check and iterator caches |
| Permify | None documented | “process-local cache; there is no shared cache layer” |
| Ory Keto | None documented | |
| Topaz | None documented | |
| Warrant | None documented |
Sources: AuthZed Materialize · OpenFGA consistency (cache flags) · Permify cache · Ory Keto docs · Topaz architecture · Warrant repository. “None documented” means the pages listed describe no such index, not that one was ruled out.
Storage
The paper stores tuples, configs and the changelog in Spanner (§3, §3.1).
| System | Datastores |
|---|---|
| Paper | Spanner |
| SpiceDB | CockroachDB, Cloud Spanner, PostgreSQL, MySQL (not recommended), memdb (development) |
| OpenFGA | memory (default), PostgreSQL, MySQL, SQLite |
| Permify | PostgreSQL, memory |
| Ory Keto | PostgreSQL, MySQL, CockroachDB, SQLite (not for production) |
| Topaz | Embedded BoltDB |
| Warrant | MySQL, PostgreSQL, SQLite |
Sources: SpiceDB datastores · Configure OpenFGA · Permify configuration · Ory deployment · Topaz architecture · Warrant migrations
License
| System | License | Language |
|---|---|---|
| SpiceDB | Apache-2.0 | Go |
| OpenFGA | Apache-2.0 | Go |
| Permify | AGPL-3.0 (Apache-2.0 from 2023-02-14 until 2025-05-12) | Go |
| Ory Keto | Apache-2.0 | Go |
| Topaz | Apache-2.0 | Go |
| Warrant | Apache-2.0 | Go |
Sources: each repository’s LICENSE file, read through the GitHub API: SpiceDB · OpenFGA · Permify · Ory Keto · Topaz · Warrant. Permify’s LICENSE file history, read at each commit that touched it: Apache-2.0 (2022-07-14), GPL-3.0 (2022-08-25), AGPL-3.0 (2022-08-26), Apache-2.0 (2023-02-14), AGPL-3.0 (2025-05-12).
Status
As of 2026-11-15.
| System | Owner | Latest release | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
| SpiceDB | AuthZed | v1.57.1 (2026-11-10) | Active |
| OpenFGA | CNCF; Okta is a core maintainer | v1.22.1 (2026-10-28) | Active, CNCF Incubating (moved 2025-10-28, announced 2025-11-11) |
| Permify | FusionAuth (acquired 2025-11-20) | v1.7.6 (2026-11-05) | Active; docs moved to fusionauth.io |
| Ory Keto | Ory | v26.2.0 (2026-03-20) | Active |
| Topaz | Its maintainers, under the aserto-dev organization |
v0.33.28 (2026-11-14) | Active; Aserto wound down as a company (2025-04-27 post) |
| Warrant | WorkOS | v1.15.1 (2024-06-10) | No release since; not archived; warrant.dev reads “Now WorkOS FGA” |
Sources: releases and repository metadata from the GitHub API for each repository above · CNCF on OpenFGA · CNCF project page · Auth0 FGA docs · Permify acquisition post · FusionAuth post · Aserto, “The final chapter” · warrant.dev
Related reading
zanzibar.tech is “The Google Zanzibar Paper, annotated by AuthZed”: the paper’s text with AuthZed’s notes alongside (“Annotations © 2026 AuthZed, Inc. Zanzibar Paper © USENIX and original authors”). Its source is on GitHub at authzed/zanzibar-annotated. The annotations are written by the company that makes SpiceDB.
Sources
- https://authzed.com/docs/spicedb/concepts/schema
- https://authzed.com/docs/spicedb/concepts/relationships
- https://authzed.com/docs/spicedb/concepts/consistency
- https://authzed.com/docs/spicedb/concepts/datastores
- https://authzed.com/docs/materialize/getting-started/overview
- https://github.com/authzed/api/blob/main/authzed/api/v1/watch_service.proto
- https://openfga.dev/docs/concepts
- https://openfga.dev/docs/configuration-language
- https://openfga.dev/docs/interacting/consistency
- https://openfga.dev/docs/getting-started/setup-openfga/configure-openfga
- https://github.com/openfga/api/blob/main/openfga/v1/openfga_service.proto
- https://fusionauth.io/permify-docs/getting-started/modeling
- https://fusionauth.io/permify-docs/getting-started/sync-data
- https://fusionauth.io/permify-docs/operations/snap-tokens
- https://fusionauth.io/permify-docs/operations/cache
- https://fusionauth.io/permify-docs/setting-up/configuration
- https://github.com/Permify/permify/blob/master/proto/base/v1/service.proto
- https://www.ory.com/docs/keto/reference/ory-permission-language
- https://www.ory.com/docs/keto/concepts/relation-tuples
- https://www.ory.com/docs/oss/deployment
- https://github.com/ory/keto/blob/master/proto/ory/keto/relation_tuples/v1alpha2/check_service.proto
- https://www.topaz.sh/docs/directory/manifest-reference
- https://www.topaz.sh/docs/architecture
- https://github.com/aserto-dev/go-directory/tree/main/proto/aserto/directory
- https://www.aserto.com/blog/the-final-chapter-for-aserto
- https://github.com/warrant-dev/warrant
- https://github.com/warrant-dev/warrant/blob/main/pkg/authz/objecttype/spec.go
- https://github.com/warrant-dev/warrant/blob/main/pkg/wookie/wookie.go
- https://warrant.dev
- https://permify.co/post/fusionauth-acquires-permify/
- https://fusionauth.io/blog/fusionauth-acquires-permify
- https://www.cncf.io/blog/2025/11/11/openfga-becomes-a-cncf-incubating-project/
- https://www.cncf.io/projects/openfga/
- https://github.com/warrant-dev/warrant/blob/main/pkg/database/sql.go
- https://docs.fga.dev/fga
- https://zanzibar.tech
- https://github.com/authzed/zanzibar-annotated